Chapter 14: Adjective Clauses (Relative Clauses)

INTERMEDIATE ENGLISH GRAMMAR
PART 3: CLAUSES
INTERMEDIATE · 19 MINUTE READ
Adjective Clauses (Relative Clauses)
A complete study of adjective clauses: the relative pronouns and adverbs, defining and non-defining clauses, that vs which, who vs whom, whose, omitting the pronoun, and reduced forms.

An adjective clause is a dependent clause that modifies a noun or pronoun. In The man who lives next door is a doctor, the clause who lives next door tells which man. Because it begins with a relative word, it is also called a relative clause, and the two terms are used together here. Adjective clauses let you pack identifying and extra information into one sentence.

This chapter covers the relative pronouns who, which, and that and the relative adverbs. You will learn the difference between defining and non-defining relative clauses, how the commas work, how to choose between that and which and between who and whom, when you may leave out the pronoun, and how to reduce a clause to a phrase. Thirty exercises and a quiz follow.

Infographic. Adjective clauses (relative clauses). They follow the noun they modify. It shows: Defining ; essential information ; no commas ; The man who called is my uncle. ; Non-defining ; extra information ; set off with commas ; My uncle, who lives in Denver, called. ; Which pronoun? ; who people ; which things ; that both, in defining clauses ; The pronoun can be omitted when it is the object of a defining clause.
Defining adjective clauses are essential and take no commas; non-defining clauses add extra information with commas. Tap or click to see it full size.
✦ In plain words

A relative clause answers the question Which one? or gives extra details about a noun. It begins with a word that points back to that noun: who, which, that, whose, where.

Why it matters: The most common problems are choosing the wrong pronoun and using commas wrongly. Both come down to one question: is the information essential or extra?

★ In brief

Summary: An adjective clause follows the noun it modifies and starts with a relative pronoun (who, whom, whose, which, that) or relative adverb (where, when, why). A defining clause is essential and takes no commas; a non-defining clause is extra and is set off by commas.

  • Who for people, which for things, that for both (in defining clauses).
  • Commas = extra information; no commas = essential information.
  • The pronoun can be omitted when it is the object of a defining clause.
  • A clause can be reduced: the man who is talking becomes the man talking.

About 19 minutes to read. Rules and examples last reviewed October 29, 2026.

IntermediateThis chapter builds on the Basic chapter Clause Definition: Introduction to Clauses. For relative clauses in depth, including sentential relatives and complex patterns, continue to Advanced Relative Clauses.

1. What Is an Adjective Clause?

An adjective clause (relative clause) is a dependent clause that does the work of an adjective: it modifies a noun or a pronoun. The noun it modifies is the antecedent, and the clause normally comes right after it.

Sentence Antecedent Adjective clause
The man who lives next door is a doctor. man who lives next door
The book that I read was long. book that I read
I met a woman whose son plays soccer. woman whose son plays soccer
This is the house where I grew up. house where I grew up

The relative word has two jobs. It links the clause to the antecedent, and it functions inside the clause as a subject, an object, or a possessive. In the man who called, who is the subject of called. In the book that I read, that is the object of read. The basic idea of dependent clauses is in the Basic chapter on clauses.

2. Relative Pronouns: Who, Which, That

💡 Memory Trick: WHO for people, WHICH for things, THAT for both!
Pronoun Refers to Function in the clause Example
who people subject The woman who called is my aunt.
whom people object The woman whom I called is my aunt.
whose people (and sometimes things) possessive The boy whose bike was stolen cried.
which things and animals subject or object The car which I bought is red.
that people or things subject or object (defining clauses only) The car that I bought is red.
Relative adverb Refers to Example
where a place the house where I grew up
when a time the day when we met
why a reason the reason why she left

The relative pronouns are introduced in the chapter on types of pronouns; the guides to relative pronouns and relative adverbs give the full rules. The sections below show how the choice between them is made.

3. Defining (Restrictive) Clauses

💡 Memory Trick: Commas = extra info, No commas = essential info!

A defining clause (also called restrictive or essential) tells which person or thing you mean. Without it, the sentence would be unclear or would mean something else. It is not set off by commas.

  • Students who study hard usually pass. only the hard-working students
  • The book that I borrowed is on the table. which book
  • I know a man whose daughter is a pilot. which man
§ The rule
Do not use commas with a defining clause. You may use who, whom, whose, which, or that. For people, who and that are both acceptable; for things, that is usual in American English.
✨ Quick Tip: Test: if you remove the clause and the sentence still identifies the same noun, the clause is non-defining. If removing it makes the noun vague, it is defining.

4. Non-Defining (Non-Restrictive) Clauses

A non-defining clause (non-restrictive or non-essential) gives extra information about a noun that is already identified. It is set off by commas, and it cannot be introduced by that.

Defining (no commas) Non-defining (commas)
My brother who lives in Dallas is a teacher. (I have more than one brother.) My brother, who lives in Dallas, is a teacher. (I have one brother.)
The car that I bought is red. My car, which I bought in May, is red.
The students who failed must retake the test. The students, who failed, must retake the test. (all of them failed)
  • Use commas before and after a clause in the middle of a sentence, and before it at the end: I met Tom, who is a doctor.
  • Proper nouns and nouns that are already unique are usually followed by a non-defining clause: Paris, which is on the Seine, is beautiful.
  • Use which for things and who for people in these clauses: my sister, who lives in Texas.
  • Do not use that: my car, that I bought in May is wrong.

Notice how the commas change the meaning in the first row: with commas, you have only one brother; without them, you have several, and the clause tells which.

5. That vs. Which

American style guides prefer that for defining clauses and which for non-defining clauses. British usage is more flexible and uses which for both.

Clause American usage Example
defining (things) that (which is acceptable but less common) The report that she wrote was long.
non-defining (things) which, with commas The report, which she wrote in May, was long.
  • After a preposition, use which, not that: the report in which she explained the plan.
  • Use that when the relative pronoun is the subject or object, never after a preposition and never in a non-defining clause.
  • If the clause is essential and you are not sure, try that; if it needs commas, use which.
⚠ When this breaks

Style guides differ on how strictly to apply the that and which distinction. Many editors follow it for consistency in formal writing, but good writers have long used which in defining clauses, particularly in British English.

6. Who vs. Whom

Use who when the pronoun is the subject of the clause and whom when it is the object of a verb or preposition.

Function Example Test
subject The woman who called is my aunt. who called (she called)
object of a verb The woman whom I called is my aunt. I called whom (I called her)
object of a preposition (formal) The woman to whom I spoke is my aunt. I spoke to whom (to her)

Replace the pronoun with he or him: if he fits, use who; if him fits, use whom. In everyday speech, who often replaces whom: The woman who I called. Formal writing keeps whom, especially right after a preposition.

⚠ Common mistake
✗The man whom is talking to Tom is my uncle.
✓The man who is talking to Tom is my uncle.

Who is the subject of is talking, so whom is wrong here. Only the object takes whom.

7. Whose in Relative Clauses

Whose shows possession and works with people and things. It is followed by a noun.

  • The girl whose bag was lost cried.
  • We visited a village whose name I forgot.
  • The company, whose profits fell, closed.
⚠ Common mistake
✗The boy who’s bike was stolen cried.
✓The boy whose bike was stolen cried.

Who’s means who is or who has. For possession, use whose.

8. Where, When, Why in Adjective Clauses

Relative adverbs introduce clauses of place, time, and reason. They are used instead of a preposition plus which.

Relative adverb Equivalent Example
where in/at/to + which This is the house where I grew up. (= in which I grew up)
when in/on/at + which, or that I remember the day when we met. (= the day that we met)
why for + which, or that That is the reason why she left. (= the reason that she left)

Where, when, and why can often be dropped: the day we met, the reason she left. The guide to relative adverbs above gives more.

9. Omitting Relative Pronouns

In a defining clause, you may leave out the relative pronoun when it is the object of the clause. You cannot leave it out when it is the subject.

Relative pronoun is… Can it be omitted? Example
object yes The book (that) I read was long.
object of a preposition at the end yes The man (whom) I spoke to is my uncle.
subject no The man who called is my uncle. (not The man called is…)
after a preposition no The man to whom I spoke is my uncle.
in a non-defining clause no My car, which I bought in May, is red.
✨ Quick Tip: To test, ask whether the next word in the clause is a subject. If it is (I read), the pronoun is the object and can go. If the next word is a verb (called), the pronoun is the subject and must stay.

10. Reduced Relative Clauses

Some relative clauses can be shortened to phrases. This is called reducing the clause. Remove the relative pronoun and any form of be.

Full clause Reduced Type
the man who is talking to Tom the man talking to Tom participial (-ing)
the book that was written by Tom the book written by Tom participial (-ed)
the first student who arrived the first student to arrive infinitive
Tom, who is a doctor, Tom, a doctor, appositive

Reduction produces tighter writing. The reduced forms are studied in the chapters on participial phrases and appositive phrases. A relative clause with no form of be can sometimes be reduced to an -ing phrase: students who study hard becomes students studying hard.

11. Agreement, Special Cases, and Errors

  • The verb agrees with the antecedent: one of the students who are late (plural: students); the only one who is late (singular).
  • Sentential relative: which can refer to a whole clause: He passed, which surprised us.
  • Prepositions: the house which I live in or the house in which I live (formal).
Error Correction Why
The man who he called is my uncle. The man whom I called is my uncle. do not repeat the pronoun
My car, that I bought in May, is red. My car, which I bought in May, is red. not that in non-defining clauses
The thing what I need is time. The thing that I need is time. what is not a relative pronoun for a noun
The man which called is my uncle. The man who called is my uncle. who for people
My sister who lives in Texas is a doctor. (I have one sister) My sister, who lives in Texas, is a doctor. add commas for extra information
✎ Worked example

Fix: The report, that she wrote it in May, was long.

  1. That cannot begin a non-defining clause: use which.
  2. It repeats the object: remove it.
  3. Result: The report, which she wrote in May, was long.
▶

Recap in 12 seconds

Watch the lesson build itself: Defining adjective clauses are essential and take no commas; non-defining clauses add extra information with commas. The video has no sound.

Exercises

Part A: Recognizing Adjective Clauses (Exercises 1–6)

Exercise 1: Find the adjective clause: The man who lives next door is a doctor.

Show Answer

Answer: who lives next door.

Exercise 2: Name the antecedent: The book that I read was long.

Show Answer

Answer: book.

Exercise 3: Name the function of who in The man who called is my uncle.

Show Answer

Answer: Subject of called.

Exercise 4: Name the function of that in The book that I read was long.

Show Answer

Answer: Object of read.

Exercise 5: Which relative adverb: the house ___ I grew up

Show Answer

Answer: where.

Exercise 6: Which relative word shows possession?

Show Answer

Answer: whose.

Part B: Who, Which, That (Exercises 7–12)

Exercise 7: Choose: The woman (who/which) called is my aunt.

Show Answer

Answer: who.

Exercise 8: Choose: The car (who/that) I bought is red.

Show Answer

Answer: that (or which).

Exercise 9: Choose: My car, (that/which) I bought in May, is red.

Show Answer

Answer: which.

Exercise 10: Choose: The report in (that/which) she explained the plan was long.

Show Answer

Answer: which.

Exercise 11: Fix it: The man which called is my uncle.

Show Answer

Answer: The man who called is my uncle.

Exercise 12: Fix it: My car, that I bought in May, is red.

Show Answer

Answer: My car, which I bought in May, is red.

Part C: Defining and Non-Defining (Exercises 13–18)

Exercise 13: Add commas if needed: My brother who lives in Dallas is a teacher. (I have one brother)

Show Answer

Answer: My brother, who lives in Dallas, is a teacher.

Exercise 14: Add commas if needed: Students who study hard usually pass.

Show Answer

Answer: No commas. The clause is essential.

Exercise 15: Add commas if needed: Paris which is on the Seine is beautiful.

Show Answer

Answer: Paris, which is on the Seine, is beautiful.

Exercise 16: Explain the difference between the sentences with and without commas: The students who failed must retake the test.

Show Answer

Answer: Without commas, only the students who failed; with commas, all the students failed.

Exercise 17: Defining or non-defining: The book that I borrowed is on the table.

Show Answer

Answer: Defining.

Exercise 18: Defining or non-defining: Tom, who is a doctor, called.

Show Answer

Answer: Non-defining.

Part D: Who/Whom and Whose (Exercises 19–23)

Exercise 19: Choose: The woman (who/whom) I called is my aunt.

Show Answer

Answer: whom (formal; who in speech).

Exercise 20: Choose: The woman (who/whom) called me is my aunt.

Show Answer

Answer: who.

Exercise 21: Choose: The woman to (who/whom) I spoke is my aunt.

Show Answer

Answer: whom.

Exercise 22: Fix it: The boy who’s bike was stolen cried.

Show Answer

Answer: The boy whose bike was stolen cried.

Exercise 23: Fix it: The man whom is talking to Tom is my uncle.

Show Answer

Answer: The man who is talking to Tom is my uncle.

Part E: Omitting and Reducing (Exercises 24–27)

Exercise 24: Can that be omitted: The book that I read was long.

Show Answer

Answer: Yes (it is the object).

Exercise 25: Can who be omitted: The man who called is my uncle.

Show Answer

Answer: No (it is the subject).

Exercise 26: Reduce: the man who is talking to Tom

Show Answer

Answer: the man talking to Tom.

Exercise 27: Reduce: the book that was written by Tom

Show Answer

Answer: the book written by Tom.

Part F: Errors (Exercises 28–30)

Exercise 28: Fix it: The man who he called is my uncle.

Show Answer

Answer: The man whom I called is my uncle. (or The man I called is my uncle.)

Exercise 29: Fix it: The thing what I need is time.

Show Answer

Answer: The thing that I need is time.

Exercise 30: Choose: One of the students who (is/are) late called.

Show Answer

Answer: are. The verb agrees with students.

Test Your Knowledge

Ready to check what you learned? Answer all 10 questions, then submit. You need 80% (8 of 10) to pass. Your answers are not stored.

Question 1:

What does an adjective clause modify?




Question 2:

Which relative pronoun refers to people?




Question 3:

Which clause needs commas?




Question 4:

Which is correct?




Question 5:

Which is correct?




Question 6:

Which can be omitted?




Question 7:

Which shows possession?




Question 8:

Which is a relative adverb?




Question 9:

What does the man talking to Tom show?




Question 10:

Which is correct?




Frequently Asked Questions

What is an adjective clause?

An adjective clause is a dependent clause that modifies a noun or pronoun. It begins with a relative pronoun or adverb and comes right after the noun it describes.

What are adjective clauses and relative clauses?

They are the same thing. Adjective clauses are called relative clauses because they begin with a relative word: who, whom, whose, which, that, where, when, or why.

What is a relative clause example?

The book that I read was long. The relative clause is that I read, and it modifies book. Another example is The man who lives next door is a doctor.

What are relative clauses used for?

Relative clauses are used to identify which person or thing you mean (defining) or to give extra information about one already identified (non-defining). They make sentences more compact.

What is the rule for who, which, that?

Use who for people, which for things, and that for either in defining clauses. In non-defining clauses, use who or which with commas, never that.

When can I omit that in a relative clause?

You can omit that (or who, whom, which) when it is the object of a defining clause: The book I read was long. You cannot omit it when it is the subject or when the clause is non-defining.

What is the difference between that and which?

In American style, that begins a defining clause and which begins a non-defining clause with commas. Which is also used after a preposition (in which), and British usage often uses which for both.

Conclusion

You now know how to use an adjective clause. You can choose between the relative pronouns who, which, and that, tell defining from non-defining clauses and punctuate them, choose between who and whom, use whose and the relative adverbs, omit a pronoun, and reduce a clause to a phrase.

Check each relative clause you write by asking whether it is essential. Next, you will study adverb clauses.

▣ Sources and further reading
  • Merriam-Webster Dictionary: relative clause: the dictionary definition of a relative clause.
  • Purdue Online Writing Lab: Grammar: reference section on clauses and relative pronouns.
  • Quirk, Randolph, et al. A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language. Longman, 1985.: restrictive and non-restrictive relative clauses.
  • Huddleston, Rodney, and Geoffrey K. Pullum. The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language. Cambridge University Press, 2002.: relative clauses and relativization.
ⓘ About this page

Last reviewed: October 29, 2026. How it was made: drafted with AI assistance, then checked with automated tests (structure, links, answer keys, spelling) and against the sources above. A person has not yet read this chapter line by line. Found a mistake? Report it.