Chapter 21: Coordination and Subordination Advanced

ADVANCED ENGLISH GRAMMAR
PART 2: ADVANCED CLAUSE STRUCTURES
ADVANCED · 24 MINUTE READ
Coordination and Subordination Advanced
A deep study of coordination and subordination: how to tell them apart, nested and complex coordination, hierarchies of subordination, mixed structures and their scope, explicit and implicit logical relationships, techniques of sentence combining, stylistic choices, and the common errors.

Coordination and subordination are the two ways of linking ideas in a sentence. In coordination, the parts have equal rank and are joined by a conjunction (She sang, and he played). In subordination, one part depends on another (She sang because he played). Advanced writers use both, often at several levels in the same sentence, and the choice decides which idea the reader treats as central. The chapters on conjunctions and clauses gave the parts; this chapter is about the techniques of sentence combining advanced writers use and the relationships that complex sentences create.

You will study how to distinguish the two processes with syntactic tests, complex coordination with multiple and nested conjunctions, subordination hierarchies with several levels of embedding, the mixing of the two in compound-complex structures and the ambiguities of scope that they create, the explicit and implicit logical relationships of coordinating subordinating structures, techniques of sentence combining, and stylistic choices such as upside-down subordination. The aim is expert coordination and well-built complex sentence relationships. Thirty editing exercises and a quiz follow.

Infographic. Coordination and subordination. Equal rank or one clause depending on another. It shows: Coordination ; equal rank ; and · but · or · nor · for · yet · so ; Subordination ; one clause depends on another ; because · although · if · when · that · who ; Three tests for subordination ; can it move? ; can it stand alone? ; backward pronoun reference ; Put the main idea in the main clause.
Coordination joins units of equal rank and subordination makes one clause depend on another; three tests tell them apart. Tap or click to see it full size.
✦ In plain words

Coordination puts ideas side by side with equal weight: It rained, and we stayed home. Subordination ranks them: Because it rained, we stayed home. The second version tells the reader which idea is the reason and which is the result.

Why it matters: Skilled sentence-building is mostly a matter of choosing the right relationship between ideas and signaling it clearly, so that the reader never has to guess.

★ In brief

Summary: Coordination joins units of equal rank (and, but, or, nor, for, yet, so); subordination makes one clause dependent on another (because, although, if, when, that, who). Tests: a subordinate clause can usually move and cannot stand alone; coordinated clauses keep their order. Complex sentences can have several levels (a subordinate clause inside a subordinate clause) and can mix both processes, so the scope of each conjunction matters. A writer chooses coordination for ideas of equal importance and subordination to rank them.

  • Coordination = equal rank; subordination = one clause depends on another.
  • Tests: movement, stand-alone, backward pronoun reference.
  • Mixed structures need clear scope: [A and B] because C vs A and [B because C].
  • Put the main idea in the main clause (avoid upside-down subordination).

About 24 minutes to read. Rules and examples last reviewed October 29, 2026.

AdvancedIntermediate readers should start with Compound-Complex Sentences, and beginners with Sentence Structure: Types of Sentences. This chapter assumes that you can already build compound, complex, and compound-complex sentences.

1. Coordination and Subordination: Equal and Unequal Relationships

💡 Memory Trick: Coordination = equal, Subordination = unequal!

Coordination links units of the same rank and category. Subordination links a dependent unit to a unit on which it depends. The conjunctions are surveyed in the chapter on advanced conjunction concepts.

Test Coordination Subordination
rank equal units a dependent clause and a main clause
can the second unit stand alone as a sentence? yes: She sang. He played. no: *Because he played.
can the units swap places? usually yes, with a change of meaning in time or sequence the dependent clause can move: Because he played, she sang / She sang because he played
conjunction position the conjunction stays between the units the conjunction goes with the dependent clause
backward pronoun reference not allowed: *He came, and Tom left (with he = Tom) allowed: When he came, Tom left (he = Tom)
ellipsis allowed: Tom came and [Tom] left restricted
punctuation comma before the conjunction between clauses comma after an introductory dependent clause
adding a second conjunction and + but in the same position is impossible a coordinator can precede a subordinator: and because

The backward-pronoun test is useful: a pronoun may precede its antecedent when the pronoun is in a subordinate clause (Before he left, Tom called) but not when the two clauses are coordinated (He left, and Tom called cannot mean that he is Tom). It shows that subordination creates a structural dependency, while coordination does not.

2. Complex Coordination: Multiple and Nested Conjunctions

Pattern Example Notes
simple series red, white, and blue; She came, she saw, she conquered. a list with a final and (syndeton)
no conjunctions (asyndeton) I came, I saw, I conquered. quick, dramatic rhythm
repeated conjunctions (polysyndeton) We laughed and cried and sang and danced. slow, cumulative rhythm
mixed conjunctions She sang, and he played, but nobody listened, so they left. a chain of clauses with different relations
nested coordination Either (the manager and the staff) or (the owner) must sign. coordinated units inside coordinated units
correlative nesting Both (young and old) and (rich and poor) came. —
coordination with different categories She is rich and in love. He is a fool and proud of it. unlike categories: informal
phrasal coordination the tall man and the short woman; to read and to write words, phrases, and clauses
Ambiguity of scope Possible meanings Fix
old men and women [old men] and [women] or [old [men and women]] old men and old women / elderly people
the manager or the owner and the staff (manager or owner) and staff, or manager or (owner and staff) use brackets in words: either the manager or the owner, together with the staff
She plays tennis and golf on Sundays. tennis (anytime) and golf on Sundays / both on Sundays On Sundays she plays tennis and golf.
bread and butter or jam (bread and butter) or jam, or bread and (butter or jam) bread with butter or jam
§ The rule
When a sentence has several conjunctions, mark the hierarchy by punctuation: a semicolon separates the larger units and commas the smaller ones inside them: She sang, danced, and juggled; he played the guitar, the drums, and the piano; and the audience cheered. Without the semicolons, it is hard to see where the units begin and end. Keep coordinated units parallel in form; see the chapter on parallel structure.

3. Subordination Hierarchies: Levels and Embedding

A subordinate clause can contain its own subordinate clause, which can contain another. The levels of embedding make a hierarchy.

Level Clause Type
0 The report is late main clause
1 because the manager said adverbial clause (reason)
2 that the data were incomplete noun clause (object of said)
3 which the team had collected relative clause (modifies data)
  • The report is late [because the manager said [that the data [which the team had collected] were incomplete]]. three levels of subordination
  • I know [that she believes [that he will win]]. two levels
  • [Although the plan [that she proposed] was costly], it succeeded. a relative clause inside an adverbial clause
Branching Example Effect on the reader
right-branching (dependent clause at the end) She said that he knew that I thought that they left. easy to read: each clause follows the previous
left-branching (dependent clause at the start) Because he knew that she would come, he waited. acceptable; a delay before the main clause
center-embedding (a clause inside the main clause) The report that the committee that the manager chose wrote was late. hard to read beyond one level; avoid more than one center-embedded clause
multiple center-embedding The rat the cat the dog chased killed ate the malt. grammatical but practically unreadable

Right-branching sentences are easiest because the reader finishes one clause before starting the next. Center-embedding strains memory because the reader must hold the subject until the verb arrives. A writer should keep the number of levels to about three, and avoid center-embedding of more than one clause. The clause types are treated in the chapters on nominal clauses, relative clauses, and adverbial clauses.

4. Mixing Coordination and Subordination: Compound-Complex Sentences

Structure Example Reading
[A and B] because C We left because it was late and the road was closed. the reason has two parts
A and [B because C] We left, and we stayed away because it was late. only the second clause has the reason
[A because B] and C We left because it was late, and we did not return. the first clause has a reason; the second is added
[Although A], B and C Although it rained, we went out and got wet. one concession; two main clauses
A, [which B], and C The plan, which was costly, succeeded, and she was promoted. relative clause inside a coordinated sentence
A because [B and C] We left because it was late and the road was closed. ambiguous with the first reading

The same words can have different structures, so the scope of the conjunction matters. We left because it was late and the road was closed can mean that two things caused the leaving ([it was late and the road was closed]) or that we left because it was late, and (also) the road was closed. Punctuation can help (We left because it was late, and the road was closed), and so can repeating the subordinator (because it was late and because the road was closed).

Repeating the subordinator Example Effect
not repeated because he was tired and hungry one reason with two parts
repeated because he was tired and because he was hungry two separate reasons; emphatic
that repeated He said that he was tired and that he was hungry. keeps the parallel structure; formal
if repeated If it rains and if it is cold, we stay. emphatic
coordinator before subordinator We stayed home, and because it rained, we read. —

5. Explicit and Implicit Logical Relationships

The relationship between two ideas can be stated explicitly by a conjunction or left implicit. Grammar offers three levels of explicitness.

Level Example Relationship
parataxis (juxtaposition) It rained. We stayed home. implied: reason and result
coordination It rained, so we stayed home. result
subordination Because it rained, we stayed home. reason
parataxis He tried hard. He failed. implied: concession
coordination He tried hard, but he failed. contrast
subordination Although he tried hard, he failed. concession
Relationship Coordinators and conjuncts Subordinators
addition and, also, moreover —
contrast but, yet, however although, though, whereas, while
reason for, since (as) because, since, as, now that
result so, therefore, thus so … that, such … that
condition or (otherwise) if, unless, provided that, as long as
time and sequence then, next, and when, after, before, while, until
purpose — so that, in order that, lest
alternative or, either … or whether … or

Explicit signals make a text easier to follow, because the reader does not have to infer the relation. But an explicit conjunction can also be wrong: and says only “addition” and may hide a relation of cause or contrast. He worked hard and he failed is less clear than He worked hard but he failed. The role of the relations in the coherence of a text is treated in a later chapter.

6. Advanced Sentence Combining

Take three short sentences: The storm hit the coast. The power failed. The city went dark. There are many ways of combining them, and each version gives the ideas a different weight.

Version Technique Emphasis
The storm hit the coast, the power failed, and the city went dark. coordination (equal) a chain of events
When the storm hit the coast, the power failed, and the city went dark. subordination (time) + coordination the storm is the time frame
The storm that hit the coast caused the power to fail, which left the city dark. relative clauses the storm and its consequences
When the storm hit the coast and the power failed, the city went dark. subordination with coordination inside the darkness is the main result
The storm hit the coast, causing the power to fail and the city to go dark. participial phrase (non-finite) the storm is the cause of two effects
After the storm’s landfall, the failure of the power left the city dark. nominalization compressed and formal
Technique Use Example
coordinate ideas of equal importance The road was closed, and the river was rising.
subordinate with a conjunction rank ideas; show the relation Because the road was closed, we stayed.
relative clause add identifying or extra information about a noun The road, which was closed, …
participial phrase reduce a clause when the subject is shared Seeing the road closed, we stayed.
appositive rename a noun The road, a narrow lane, …
absolute phrase add circumstance The road closed, we stayed.
nominalization compress for formal style The closure of the road kept us home.

7. Stylistic Choices: When to Coordinate and When to Subordinate

Coordinate when Subordinate when
two ideas are equally important one idea is less important or supporting
you want a parallel, balanced effect you want to show a reason, condition, concession, or time
the ideas are a sequence of events one idea sets the background for another
you want a quick, rhythmic effect you want a precise logical relation
Fault Example Fix
stringy sentence (excess coordination) We went to the market, and we bought apples, and then we went home, and it started to rain, and we got wet. Because it started to rain as we went home from the market, where we had bought apples, we got wet.
choppy sequence (no coordination or subordination) We went to the market. We bought apples. We went home. It rained. After we bought apples at the market, we went home in the rain.
upside-down subordination (the main idea in the dependent clause) He was driving at 90 miles an hour when he was stopped by the police. He was stopped by the police when he was driving at 90 miles an hour. / Driving at 90 miles an hour, he was stopped by the police.
excessive embedding The report that the committee that the manager chose wrote was late. The report written by the committee that the manager chose was late.
wrong relation He is tall and he can’t play basketball. Although he is tall, he can’t play basketball.
⚠ When this breaks

Upside-down subordination is a term used by writing teachers for a sentence that puts the important information in a dependent clause. Although she won the Nobel Prize, she was born in a small town subordinates the prize; if the prize is the point, make it the main clause: She won the Nobel Prize, although she was born in a small town. The two versions say the same, but they stress different facts.

Spoken English relies on coordination and clause chaining (and … and … so …), while academic writing uses more subordination and embedding. The choice of style depends on genre. Writers also use periodic sentences (the main clause comes late, building suspense) and loose sentences (the main clause comes first, followed by details).

8. Punctuation Across the Hierarchy

Structure Punctuation Example
coordinated independent clauses comma + coordinator It rained, and we stayed.
coordinated clauses with internal commas semicolon (before the coordinator) Although it rained, we went; and although we were tired, we stayed.
introductory dependent clause comma after it When it rains, we stay.
final dependent clause (essential) no comma We stay when it rains.
final dependent clause (contrast) comma We stayed, although it rained.
nonrestrictive relative clause commas The plan, which was costly, succeeded.
compound predicate no comma She opened the door and walked in.
correlative pair joining clauses comma between clauses Either you leave, or I will.
conjunctive adverb joining clauses semicolon before; comma after It rained; therefore, we stayed.

9. Common Errors in Coordination and Subordination

Error Correction Rule
It rained, we stayed. It rained, so we stayed. comma splice
Because it rained. We stayed. Because it rained, we stayed. fragment
Although it rained, but we went. Although it rained, we went. double conjunction
Because it rained, so we stayed. Because it rained, we stayed. double conjunction
She is smart and a good teacher and kind. She is smart, kind, and a good teacher. parallel forms
We went, and it rained, and we got wet, and we went home. We went out, but it rained and we got wet, so we went home. stringy coordination; vary the relations
He was driving 90 when he was stopped by the police. (upside-down) He was stopped by the police when he was driving 90. main idea in the main clause
The report that the committee that the manager chose wrote was late. The report written by the committee that the manager chose was late. excessive center-embedding
While she likes tea, he prefers coffee. (ambiguous) Whereas she likes tea, he prefers coffee. while can mean time
We left because it was late and the road was closed. (ambiguous) We left because it was late and because the road was closed. scope
Either he comes, nor I leave. Either he comes or I leave. either … or
She sang, and he is playing, but they left. She sang, and he played, but they left. consistent tense
✎ Worked example

Edit: It rained, we stayed, because it rained. So we read, and because it was dark, so we slept, and we went to bed, and although it was late, but we were happy, and she was driving 90 when she was stopped by the police, and the report that the committee that the manager chose wrote was late.

  1. It rained, we stayed, because it rained: comma splice and repetition: Because it rained, we stayed.
  2. So we read: starts with a coordinator: We read.
  3. because it was dark, so we slept: double conjunction: because it was dark, we slept.
  4. although it was late, but we were happy: although it was late, we were happy.
  5. she was driving 90 when she was stopped by the police: upside-down: the police stopped her when she was driving 90.
  6. the report that the committee that the manager chose wrote was late: the report written by the committee that the manager chose was late.
  7. Result: Because it rained, we stayed and read. Because it was dark, we slept, and although it was late, we were happy. The police stopped her when she was driving 90, and the report written by the committee that the manager chose was late.
▶

Recap in 12 seconds

Watch the lesson build itself: Coordination joins units of equal rank and subordination makes one clause depend on another; three tests tell them apart. The video has no sound.

Exercises

Part A: Telling Them Apart (Exercises 1–6)

Exercise 1: Coordination or subordination: She sang, and he played.

Show Answer

Answer: Coordination.

Exercise 2: Coordination or subordination: She sang because he played.

Show Answer

Answer: Subordination.

Exercise 3: Which clause can stand alone: Because he played or He played?

Show Answer

Answer: He played.

Exercise 4: Can the clauses swap places: Because he played, she sang and She sang because he played?

Show Answer

Answer: Yes (subordination).

Exercise 5: Which allows backward pronoun reference: When he came, Tom left or He came, and Tom left?

Show Answer

Answer: When he came, Tom left.

Exercise 6: Which rank do coordinated units have?

Show Answer

Answer: Equal rank.

Part B: Complex Coordination (Exercises 7–12)

Exercise 7: Name the device: I came, I saw, I conquered.

Show Answer

Answer: Asyndeton.

Exercise 8: Name the device: We laughed and cried and sang and danced.

Show Answer

Answer: Polysyndeton.

Exercise 9: Disambiguate: old men and women

Show Answer

Answer: old men and old women (or elderly people).

Exercise 10: Punctuate the large units: She sang, danced, and juggled and he played the guitar, drums, and piano.

Show Answer

Answer: …juggled; and he played …

Exercise 11: Edit: She is smart and a good teacher and kind.

Show Answer

Answer: She is smart, kind, and a good teacher.

Exercise 12: Edit: Either he comes, nor I leave.

Show Answer

Answer: Either he comes or I leave.

Part C: Subordination Hierarchies (Exercises 13–18)

Exercise 13: Count the levels: I know that she believes that he will win.

Show Answer

Answer: Two levels of subordination.

Exercise 14: Name the branching: She said that he knew that I thought that they left.

Show Answer

Answer: Right-branching.

Exercise 15: Name the problem: The report that the committee that the manager chose wrote was late.

Show Answer

Answer: Center-embedding (hard to read).

Exercise 16: Rewrite: The report that the committee that the manager chose wrote was late.

Show Answer

Answer: The report written by the committee that the manager chose was late.

Exercise 17: Name the clause type: that the data were incomplete in the manager said that the data were incomplete

Show Answer

Answer: A noun clause (object).

Exercise 18: How many levels are advisable at most?

Show Answer

Answer: About three.

Part D: Mixed Structures and Relationships (Exercises 19–24)

Exercise 19: Explain the two readings: We left because it was late and the road was closed.

Show Answer

Answer: One reason with two parts; or the reason is lateness, and the road was also closed.

Exercise 20: Make the reasons separate: because it was late and the road was closed

Show Answer

Answer: because it was late and because the road was closed.

Exercise 21: Name the relationship: Although he tried hard, he failed.

Show Answer

Answer: Concession.

Exercise 22: Name the level: It rained. We stayed.

Show Answer

Answer: Parataxis (implicit relation).

Exercise 23: Make the relation explicit (subordination): He tried hard. He failed.

Show Answer

Answer: Although he tried hard, he failed.

Exercise 24: Choose: He worked hard (and/but) he failed.

Show Answer

Answer: but.

Part E: Style and Errors (Exercises 25–30)

Exercise 25: Fix the upside-down subordination: He was driving at 90 when he was stopped by the police.

Show Answer

Answer: He was stopped by the police when he was driving at 90.

Exercise 26: Fix the stringy sentence: We went to the market, and we bought apples, and then we went home.

Show Answer

Answer: After buying apples at the market, we went home.

Exercise 27: Edit: It rained, we stayed.

Show Answer

Answer: It rained, so we stayed.

Exercise 28: Edit: Although it rained, but we went.

Show Answer

Answer: Although it rained, we went.

Exercise 29: Edit: While she likes tea, he prefers coffee. (to avoid ambiguity)

Show Answer

Answer: Whereas she likes tea, he prefers coffee.

Exercise 30: Define a periodic sentence.

Show Answer

Answer: A sentence whose main clause comes late, building suspense.

Test Your Knowledge

Ready to check what you learned? Answer all 10 questions, then submit. You need 80% (8 of 10) to pass. Your answers are not stored.

Question 1:

What is coordination?




Question 2:

What is subordination?




Question 3:

Which can stand alone?




Question 4:

Which allows he to precede Tom?




Question 5:

Which is upside-down subordination?




Question 6:

Which is right-branching?




Question 7:

Which is correct?




Question 8:

Which is a comma splice?




Question 9:

Which is stringy?




Question 10:

Which punctuation separates larger units with internal commas?




Frequently Asked Questions

What are coordination and subordination?

Coordination links units of equal rank with a coordinator (and, but, or); subordination links a dependent clause to a main clause with a subordinator (because, although, if) or a relative word.

What is sentence combining advanced?

Advanced sentence combining is joining short sentences into longer ones with coordination, subordination, relative clauses, participial and appositive phrases, and nominalizations, choosing the structure that gives the ideas the right weight.

What are coordinating subordinating structures?

Coordinating subordinating structures are sentences that use both processes: compound-complex sentences with coordinated clauses, dependent clauses, and relative clauses at several levels.

What are complex sentence relationships?

Complex sentence relationships are the logical links between clauses in a sentence: addition, contrast, reason, result, condition, concession, time, and purpose, signaled by conjunctions and conjuncts, or left implicit.

What is expert coordination?

Expert coordination is the use of coordination with control: parallel forms, clear scope, correct punctuation at each level, and a choice between coordination and subordination that suits the ideas.

What is upside-down subordination?

Upside-down subordination is the placing of the main idea in a dependent clause and a secondary idea in the main clause, as in He was driving at 90 when he was stopped by the police.

When should I coordinate and when subordinate?

Coordinate ideas of equal importance, and subordinate the less important idea or the one that gives a reason, condition, concession, or time.

Conclusion

You now have a deep study of coordination and subordination: the tests that separate them, complex and nested coordination, subordination hierarchies, mixed structures and scope, explicit and implicit relationships, sentence combining, style, and punctuation across the hierarchy. You can build complex sentences with expert control.

When you write a long sentence, ask which ideas are equal and which depend on others, and make the structure show it. This chapter ends Part 2; next, you begin the advanced verb system with tense and aspect.

◆ New guides on related topics
▣ Sources and further reading
  • Huddleston, Rodney, and Geoffrey K. Pullum. The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language. Cambridge University Press, 2002.: the reference analysis of coordination and subordination.
  • Quirk, Randolph, et al. A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language. Longman, 1985.: the classic treatment of coordination, subordination, and condensed clauses.
  • Biber, Douglas, et al. Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English. Longman, 1999.: corpus evidence on the use of coordination and subordination in speech and writing.
  • Christensen, Francis. “A Generative Rhetoric of the Sentence.” College Composition and Communication 14 (1963): 155–161.: the cumulative sentence.
  • Merriam-Webster Dictionary: subordination: the dictionary entry.
ⓘ About this page

Last reviewed: October 29, 2026. How it was made: drafted with AI assistance, then checked with automated tests (structure, links, answer keys, spelling) and against the sources above. A person has not yet read this chapter line by line. Found a mistake? Report it.