Chapter 65: Grammar Myths and Controversies

ADVANCED ENGLISH GRAMMAR
PART 7: STYLISTIC GRAMMAR
ADVANCED · 29 MINUTE READ
Grammar Myths and Controversies
A study of grammar myths and controversies: fifty common “rules” that are not rules (split infinitives, stranded prepositions, sentences that begin with conjunctions), where they came from, the difference between prescriptive and descriptive grammar, how usage evolves, the main controversies (singular they, the serial comma, which and that, data, hopefully, who and whom), regional variation, formal and informal norms, and how to decide when a rule matters.

Grammar myths are statements about “correct” English that people repeat with confidence and that the evidence does not support: never split an infinitive, never end a sentence with a preposition, never begin a sentence with and or but. Many were invented by eighteenth- and nineteenth-century writers who wished to make English more like Latin, or simply to record their own tastes, and they were passed down in classrooms as laws. Good writers have always broken them. Other points are real controversies: educated writers and usage guides disagree about them, and the disagreement is itself part of the history of the language.

This chapter separates the myths from the genuine questions. You will meet fifty common grammar rules myths with the evidence against them, the difference between prescriptive and descriptive grammar, the way that language evolves, the main grammar controversies (singular they, the serial comma, which and that, and others), regional variation, and the question of when a rule does matter: in an exam, a style guide, an academic journal, or a job application. The aim is not to abandon rules but to know what kind of rule each one is. Debunking grammar myths helps a writer to choose by evidence and by the needs of the reader, and to avoid language myths about “correctness”. Thirty editing exercises and a quiz follow.

Infographic. Grammar myths and controversies. A myth is a rule the evidence does not support. It shows: Split infinitives ; the ban is a myth ; Ending with a preposition ; the ban is a myth ; Two views ; prescriptive: how people should write · descriptive: how people write ; Controversies ; decide by evidence, genre, and house style ; Correctness ; Context determines correctness..
Grammar myths are supposed rules that usage does not support; controversies are decided by evidence, genre, and house style. Tap or click to see it full size.
✦ In plain words

Some grammar “rules” are real: they describe what almost every speaker does, and breaking them makes a sentence ungrammatical (*He go home). Others are myths: they were taught as rules, but careful writers have always ignored them, and following them can make a sentence worse.

Why it matters: A third group are matters of style or convention: an exam, an editor, or a style guide may require a particular choice. The skill is to tell the three apart, and to follow the rule that your reader and your purpose require.

★ In brief

Summary: A grammar myth is a supposed rule that the evidence from usage and from the history of English does not support: for example, that infinitives must not be split, that sentences must not end with prepositions, or that they must not begin with conjunctions. Prescriptive grammar tells people how to use language; descriptive grammar records how they do. Language evolves, and many once-condemned usages are now standard. Genuine controversies remain (singular they, the serial comma, which versus that), and the answer often depends on context, genre, and the house style of the reader. Rules matter most where an audience, a test, or a style guide requires them; elsewhere, clarity and the reader’s expectations are the guide.

  • A myth is a “rule” the evidence does not support.
  • Prescriptive = how people should write; descriptive = how people do.
  • Controversies: decide by evidence, genre, and house style.
  • Context determines correctness.

About 29 minutes to read. Rules and examples last reviewed October 29, 2026.

AdvancedIntermediate readers should start with Common Grammar Errors, and beginners with Basic Grammar Review. This chapter assumes that you know the standard rules of grammar and can recognize the structures named in the myths.

1. Grammar Myths: Fifty “Rules” That Are Not Rules

💡 Memory Trick: Context determines correctness!

The statements below are among the most widely repeated claims about English. For each, the table gives the verdict of current usage guides and grammars, with the reason. “Not a rule” means that careful writers use the construction freely; it does not mean that it is always the best choice. A few entries are real preferences in some contexts, and are marked.

# The “rule” Verdict Why
1 Never split an infinitive (to boldly go). Myth English infinitives are two words; splitting is natural, and sometimes avoiding it is awkward or changes the meaning.
2 Never end a sentence with a preposition. Myth Stranded prepositions are standard in speech and writing: the book you asked about.
3 Never begin a sentence with and, but, or because. Myth Coordinators and subordinators begin sentences in good writing; avoid a fragment, not the word.
4 Never use I in academic writing. Myth (varies by field) Many fields and style guides accept I and we where the writer’s role matters.
5 Never use contractions in writing. Context Fine in informal and neutral prose; avoid in formal documents.
6 The passive voice is always bad. Myth It is useful when the actor is unknown or unimportant (see the chapter on voice).
7 A paragraph must have at least three sentences (or five). Myth A paragraph needs one main idea, however many sentences develop it.
8 Never use a one-sentence paragraph. Myth Used sparingly for emphasis; common in journalism and fiction.
9 Never use a fragment. Myth Deliberate fragments are standard in creative and informal writing.
10 Since can only mean time, not reason. Myth Both senses have been used since the Middle Ages; avoid it only where ambiguous.
11 Use that for restrictive clauses and which for non-restrictive ones. Convention A widely taught house-style rule that many writers do not follow; see the controversies below.
12 None must take a singular verb. Myth None may take a singular or a plural verb, depending on meaning.
13 Whom must be used for all objects. Context Whom is formal and fading in speech; who is normal in most informal contexts.
14 Use fewer for countable nouns and less for uncountable ones, without exception. Context A useful distinction in formal writing, but less than with quantities (less than 10 miles) has long been standard.
15 Hopefully must not mean “it is hoped that”. Myth A sentence adverb like fortunately; accepted by most modern guides.
16 Different than is wrong; use different from. Disputed Both are used by educated writers; from is safer in formal writing.
17 Double negatives are always illogical. Myth Standard in many dialects and languages for emphasis; and not unlikely is a legitimate litotes. Avoid in formal standard English.
18 Between is for two, among for more than two. Myth Between is also used for relations among several distinct items.
19 Can asks ability; may asks permission, and can is wrong for permission. Myth Can for permission is long established in speech; may is more formal.
20 Each other is for two, one another for more. Myth The two are interchangeable in practice.
21 Over cannot mean “more than”. Myth Common in good writing; some house styles prefer more than.
22 Data is always plural. Context Plural in many scientific styles; singular as a mass noun is standard in general use.
23 They cannot be singular. Myth Singular they has been used since the fourteenth century.
24 Impact cannot be a verb. Myth Verb use is common; some readers dislike it.
25 Gotten is not good English. Myth Standard in American English; not used in the same way in British English.
26 Irregardless is not a word. Nonstandard It is in dictionaries, labeled nonstandard; use regardless.
27 You must not use they to refer to a company. Variety Common in British English; American usage prefers it.
28 A sentence must have a subject and a verb (so imperatives are wrong). Myth Imperatives have an implied subject.
29 You must not use like as a conjunction. Disputed Common in speech; many formal guides prefer as or as if.
30 Comprise cannot be used in the passive (is comprised of). Disputed Widely used; some guides still object.
31 Literally cannot be used for emphasis. Disputed Used for emphasis since the eighteenth century; many guides advise against it in formal writing.
32 Enormity must mean “wickedness”, never “size”. Disputed The size sense is common; the older sense is clearer in formal writing.
33 Whose cannot refer to things. Myth Whose is the standard possessive relative, for things as well as people.
34 Never use very. Style A matter of style, not grammar.
35 Never use the same word twice in a sentence. Myth Repetition is often better than a forced synonym.
36 Use two spaces after a period. Convention A typewriter-era habit; modern style guides prefer one.
37 A comma goes wherever you pause. Myth Commas follow grammar and convention, not breathing.
38 Never use a comma before and. Myth A serial comma is standard in many styles; the comma between independent clauses is required in most.
39 Never end a sentence with an adverb or a participle. Myth There is no such rule.
40 Everyone is plural, so use their. Variety Everyone takes a singular verb; their is accepted as singular.
41 Never write numerals in prose. Style Style guides differ on when to use words and when numerals.
42 “A lot” is one word. Myth (spelling) Two words; the one-word form is a misspelling.
43 Alright is wrong. Disputed Used widely; all right is safer in formal writing.
44 A sentence cannot begin with a numeral. Convention A style rule in some guides; rephrase or spell out.
45 You must not use so as an intensifier (so tired). Myth An ordinary intensifier.
46 The apostrophe is dying out, so rules do not matter. Myth Its use is stable in standard written English.
47 Adjectives must always precede nouns. Myth Postposed adjectives exist (attorney general, something strange).
48 Prepositions cannot be repeated or dropped in coordination. Myth Style choice; see the chapter on parallel structure.
49 Shall is for the first person and will for others. Obsolete An old textbook distinction that most speakers do not make.
50 English has no future tense because it has no inflected future. Misleading English expresses the future in several ways, including will and be going to; the category depends on definitions.

Several of these items were taught by grammar writers of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, who often appealed to Latin or to logic. The best-known early example is the criticism of a preposition at the end of a clause by the poet John Dryden in 1672, and a later influence is Robert Lowth’s A Short Introduction to English Grammar (1762), which has been widely cited as a source of prescriptive rules. The influence of these writers on modern myths is sometimes exaggerated, but the pattern is clear: a rule is stated, repeated in schoolbooks, and taken for a law of the language. See also the chapter on diction for the confusable words that are the other staple of such debates.

2. Prescriptive vs Descriptive Grammar

Feature Prescriptive Descriptive
aim to say how language should be used to record and explain how language is used
basis authority, tradition, taste, logic, Latin evidence from speech and writing; corpora
typical source style guides, usage dictionaries, school rules linguistic grammars, corpus studies
attitude to variation prefers one standard form treats variation as natural data
example “Do not split infinitives.” “Split infinitives occur in x percent of infinitive constructions in written English.”
strength gives a clear standard; useful for editing and teaching accurate; explains why people write as they do
weakness may rest on false claims; may treat style as law may seem to say that anything goes
used for exams, house style, editing linguistics, dictionaries, language research
Kind of statement Example Status
a description of what is grammatical in a variety She likes tea, not *Likes she tea descriptive fact
a recommendation of style Prefer the active voice. prescription (style advice)
a requirement of a style guide Use the serial comma. prescription (convention)
a social judgment Using ain’t marks a speaker as uneducated. a claim about prestige, not grammar
a claim about history They cannot be singular. checkable (and false)
  • Descriptive does not mean “anything goes”. Describing usage includes describing the standard and the penalties for departing from it in particular contexts.
  • Prescriptive advice can be good advice. A recommendation to avoid ambiguity or to keep a consistent style is sound; the fault is in presenting preferences as laws.
  • Check the claim. Is it a fact about usage, a matter of style, a house rule, or a social prejudice?
  • Linguists mostly work descriptively; usage panels and editors mostly work prescriptively. Both have a place.
  • Respect the reader’s expectations. Even if a rule is a myth, a reader who believes it may judge you; that is a cost to weigh.

The difference between the two approaches has been debated since the eighteenth century, and it comes up again in the discussion of language change in the next chapters. A balanced view is that grammar can be studied as a science (description) and used as a craft (prescription), and the craft is better when it rests on the science.

3. Evolving Language: Usages That Were Once Condemned

Usage Once criticized as Now
singular they ungrammatical widely accepted; recommended by many major style guides
hopefully as a sentence adverb illogical standard in informal and general writing
is being built (progressive passive) an incorrect “new” form (c. 1800) standard
contact, impact, text, google as verbs improper noun-to-verb shifts verbs in general use
who for whom careless normal in speech and informal writing
like as a conjunction vulgar common in speech; formal writing prefers as
gotten (American) an error standard in American English
different than incorrect used by educated writers, mostly in American English
between you and I — a hypercorrection; between you and me is standard
fun as an adjective (a fun time) noun only accepted
decimate for “destroy” must mean “kill one in ten” the broad sense is standard; the narrow sense is rare
nice (originally “foolish”) — the meaning changed over centuries
ain’t illiterate nonstandard in writing; used in dialects and informal speech for effect
split infinitives a violation of Latin-based “logic” accepted

The pattern is consistent: a new use arises in speech, is criticized by some writers, spreads, and often becomes standard, after which the criticism is forgotten or remembered as a curiosity. Not every change succeeds, and the speed varies. These changes are the subject of the following chapters, on the history of English grammar and on language change in modern English, and the way to measure them is described in the chapter on corpus linguistics.

4. Grammar Controversies: Where Experts Disagree

Issue Positions Practical advice
singular they accepted as a gender-neutral singular (historic and modern) versus rejected by some formal guides use it for an unknown person and for a person who uses they; follow your style guide
serial (Oxford) comma AP-style journalism omits it; many academic and book publishers use it use it consistently; add it when its absence causes ambiguity
which versus that (restrictive) taught as a rule in American style guides; British usage uses which more freely follow your house style; use commas to mark non-restrictive clauses
data singular or plural plural in formal scientific writing; singular in general use follow your field
who versus whom whom required in formal writing; who accepted in speech use whom in formal writing after prepositions
split infinitive accepted by modern guides split it if the alternative is awkward
ending with a preposition accepted avoid only if the result is clumsy
comprise / compose is comprised of disputed use is composed of in formal writing
less / fewer distinction required by some guides use fewer for count nouns in formal writing
over / more than AP once distinguished; now accepts over follow your guide
since / because ambiguity of since disliked by some use because for reason in formal writing
whose for inanimate antecedents accepted use
there is + plural noun agreement dispute (there’s two reasons) plural in formal writing
I versus me after than and as taller than I (formal) versus taller than me (common) either; formal writing prefers the subject form
they/their with a singular antecedent everyone … their accepted
literally as an intensifier disputed avoid in formal writing
try and versus try to try and informal try to in formal writing
numerals versus words style guides differ follow the guide
it’s versus its confusion a real error, not a controversy learn the difference
hyphens and compounds (email / e-mail) spelling conventions change follow the dictionary or the house style
e.g. and i.e. with commas styles differ follow the guide
capitalization of titles and headings sentence case versus title case follow the guide
American versus British punctuation of quotations different conventions follow the variety of your reader (see the chapter on British vs American English)

When experts disagree, there is rarely a single right answer. The sensible course is to know the options, to know which your reader prefers (or which a style guide requires), and to be consistent. A claim that something is “always wrong” in a disputed area is a reason to doubt the claim.

5. Regional and Social Variation

Feature One variety Another variety Note
collective nouns (the team …) The team is winning. (American) The team are winning. (British) both standard in their varieties
have got for possession less common: Do you have a pen? common: Have you got a pen? different frequency
past participle of get gotten (American) got (British) —
shall rare more common (especially in questions: Shall we go?) —
at the weekend / on the weekend on the weekend (American) at the weekend (British) —
subjunctive after suggest I suggest that he go (American) I suggest that he should go (British, also goes) both occur in each variety
invariant tag isn’t it? for any statement (widespread in several Englishes) the standard tag agrees with the verb a feature of several varieties
stative verbs in the progressive (I am knowing) nonstandard in most varieties reported in some second-language and contact varieties varieties, not errors
prepone unknown in many varieties used in Indian English for “bring forward” —
only for emphasis — used widely in Indian English (He came yesterday only) —
Dimension of variation Examples
region American, British, Australian, Indian, Nigerian, Singaporean, Caribbean Englishes
social class and education prestige forms versus stigmatized forms (ain’t, double negatives)
register formal versus informal
age generational slang and new constructions (see the chapter on language change)
medium speech versus writing, texting versus formal
ethnicity and community dialects with their own regular grammar

Each variety has regular grammar of its own, and a feature that is “wrong” in one standard may be normal in another. The major differences between British and American English are the subject of the next chapter, and varieties of English around the world have their own standards and traditions. A writer chooses the variety that suits the reader and keeps it consistent.

6. Formal vs Informal Rules: Context Matters

Feature Formal writing Informal writing
contractions avoided natural
sentence-initial and/but used sparingly common
stranded prepositions accepted, but a fronted preposition is possible (about which) natural
whom used after prepositions and as an object rare
I / we depends on the field natural
fragments avoided common
passive common in some fields less common
they as singular accepted by many guides natural
slang and colloquial vocabulary avoided natural
can for permission may preferred can
like as conjunction as if common
abbreviations and texting forms avoided natural

The same sentence can be correct in one setting and wrong in another. I ain’t got no time is a perfectly regular sentence in a dialect and would be inappropriate in a formal report; The reviewer was unable to ascertain the veracity of the claim is formal and may be out of place in a text message. This is the sense of the memory trick of this chapter: context determines correctness. The choice of register is also discussed in the chapter on register and style.

7. When Rules Matter: Academic, Professional, and Test Contexts

Context What matters Example
academic writing the conventions of the field and the journal; formal register; consistent citation (see the chapter on academic writing) follow APA or MLA; avoid contractions; check whether I is allowed
professional and business writing clarity, courtesy, and the house style of the organization use the company style guide; keep a consistent tone (see the chapter on business writing)
legal and technical documents precision and consistency; sometimes fixed forms define terms; use one modal for one meaning
standardized tests and exams the conventions that the test treats as correct (for example subject–verb agreement, punctuation, and idiom) learn the test’s conventions; they do not test myths such as the split infinitive, but they do test pronoun agreement and fragments
editing for a publisher the house style sheet serial comma, spelling variety, hyphenation
job applications and first impressions error-free text and an appropriate tone proofread; avoid typos and wrong words
teaching and learning a clear model of the standard teach the standard as one variety among many, and explain why
Question to ask about any rule Why
Is it a fact of grammar, a style preference, or a house rule? tells you how binding it is
Is there evidence from good writers (a corpus, a usage guide)? tests the claim
Does it serve clarity or help the reader? the main purpose of a rule
Does my reader, editor, or examiner require it? the practical test
What will it cost me to break it? What will it cost to follow it? weigh the effect on meaning and on the reader’s opinion of you
Can I avoid the issue by rewording? often the simplest solution

The practical rule is: follow the rule your reader expects, and know why. If a rule is a myth, you may break it where you have a reason; if a rule is a convention you are required to follow, follow it without complaint; and if it is a real rule of grammar, follow it unless you are deliberately using a different variety or a literary effect. The treatment of editing in the chapter on editing and proofreading gives the practical steps.

8. How to Evaluate a Grammar Claim

  1. State the claim exactly. “You should never split an infinitive” is a claim of a particular strength.
  2. Look for the source. Who first made the claim, and why? Latin analogy and personal taste are weak grounds.
  3. Check usage. Do published writers whom you respect use the construction? A corpus (a large collection of real text) can answer this (see the chapter on corpus linguistics).
  4. Check a modern usage guide or a reference grammar: they report the evidence and the range of opinion.
  5. Ask what the rule is for. Does it prevent ambiguity, mark a register, or serve a convention?
  6. Decide in context. The reader, genre, and purpose decide.
Source Kind of authority
reference grammars (for example Huddleston and Pullum; Quirk et al.; Biber et al.) descriptive; evidence-based
usage guides (for example Garner; Fowler; Merriam-Webster’s usage dictionary) prescriptive and descriptive, with evidence
style guides (AP, Chicago, APA, MLA) house style conventions
dictionaries record usage and label it (formal, informal, nonstandard)
corpora data on actual frequency
school rules and folk wisdom often myths; test them

9. Common Errors in Thinking About Grammar

Error Example Better
treating a style preference as a law “Never use the passive.” Use the passive when the actor is unknown or unimportant.
treating a real rule as a myth “Grammar is just opinion, so He go home is fine.” Standard grammar has real rules; know which are which.
over-correcting (hypercorrection) between you and I; whom for who between you and me
avoiding a natural construction to obey a myth an awkward rewrite to avoid ending with a preposition keep the natural sentence
“correcting” others in public — respect the reader; correct only when asked or needed
believing that change is decay “Language is getting worse.” Language changes; some changes simplify, some add.
believing that anything goes “There are no rules.” There are conventions, and they matter in context.
mixing varieties American spelling with British punctuation choose one variety
assuming one authority “My teacher said so.” check evidence from several sources
ignoring the reader — write for the reader’s expectations
using a myth in an exam answer without checking the test’s rules — learn the test’s conventions
quoting a “rule” without a source — cite a guide or a grammar
confusing formal with correct Everything formal is right. Formal is a register, not a standard of truth
✎ Worked example

Edit: Never split an infinitive, and never end a sentence with a preposition, and never begin with a conjunction, so “To boldly go” is wrong and the person to whom I gave it, they are a good friend whom I trust, and hopefully irregardless of whom you ask they will say the same, between you and I.

  1. Never split an infinitive … never end with a preposition … never begin with a conjunction: three myths; none is a rule. (delete the claims)
  2. “To boldly go” is wrong: a myth; the split infinitive is standard: to boldly go is acceptable.
  3. the person to whom I gave it, they are a good friend whom I trust: a fronted preposition is correct but formal, and they … a good friend is a mismatch: the person I gave it to is a good friend whom I trust (or a good friend I trust).
  4. hopefully: accepted by most guides; keep or use I hope in formal writing.
  5. irregardless: nonstandard: regardless.
  6. of whom you ask they: of whomever you ask, that person will say the same (formal), or whoever you ask will say the same.
  7. between you and I: hypercorrection: between you and me.
  8. Result: The person I gave it to is a good friend I trust, and I hope that, regardless of whom you ask, the answer will be the same, between you and me. (the passage is invented; the fixes keep the natural constructions and remove the only real errors)
▶

Recap in 12 seconds

Watch the lesson build itself: Grammar myths are supposed rules that usage does not support; controversies are decided by evidence, genre, and house style. The video has no sound.

Exercises

Part A: Myths (Exercises 1–7)

Exercise 1: Is “never split an infinitive” a rule or a myth?

Show Answer

Answer: A myth.

Exercise 2: Is “never end a sentence with a preposition” a rule or a myth?

Show Answer

Answer: A myth.

Exercise 3: Is “never begin a sentence with and” a rule or a myth?

Show Answer

Answer: A myth.

Exercise 4: Is “the passive voice is always bad” a rule or a myth?

Show Answer

Answer: A myth.

Exercise 5: Is *He go home grammatical in standard English?

Show Answer

Answer: No (a real rule of agreement).

Exercise 6: Is “use two spaces after a period” a rule?

Show Answer

Answer: A typewriter-era convention; modern guides prefer one space.

Exercise 7: Name one reason that myths arise.

Show Answer

Answer: Latin analogy, taste, schoolbook repetition.

Part B: Prescriptive and Descriptive (Exercises 8–12)

Exercise 8: Define prescriptive grammar.

Show Answer

Answer: Rules for how language should be used.

Exercise 9: Define descriptive grammar.

Show Answer

Answer: An account of how language is actually used.

Exercise 10: Does descriptive mean “anything goes”?

Show Answer

Answer: No.

Exercise 11: Give a source of descriptive evidence.

Show Answer

Answer: A corpus; a reference grammar.

Exercise 12: Is “Prefer the active voice” a fact or a style recommendation?

Show Answer

Answer: A style recommendation.

Part C: Language Change and Controversies (Exercises 13–20)

Exercise 13: Name a usage once criticized and now standard.

Show Answer

Answer: Singular they; hopefully; is being built; verbs such as contact and text.

Exercise 14: Since when has singular they been used?

Show Answer

Answer: Since the fourteenth century.

Exercise 15: Which style typically omits the serial comma?

Show Answer

Answer: Journalistic (AP) style.

Exercise 16: Which is usually taught for restrictive clauses in American style guides: that or which?

Show Answer

Answer: that.

Exercise 17: Correct: between you and I

Show Answer

Answer: between you and me.

Exercise 18: Name a nonstandard word listed in dictionaries.

Show Answer

Answer: irregardless; ain’t.

Exercise 19: Is gotten standard in American English?

Show Answer

Answer: Yes.

Exercise 20: Which is safer in formal writing: different from or different than?

Show Answer

Answer: different from.

Part D: Variation and Context (Exercises 21–26)

Exercise 21: Name a difference between American and British collective nouns.

Show Answer

Answer: The team is (American) / the team are (British).

Exercise 22: Is a feature of another variety an error?

Show Answer

Answer: Not necessarily; it may be standard in that variety.

Exercise 23: Name a formal-writing choice.

Show Answer

Answer: No contractions; whom; avoid fragments.

Exercise 24: Name an informal-writing choice.

Show Answer

Answer: Contractions; sentence-initial and; fragments.

Exercise 25: What is the memory trick of this chapter?

Show Answer

Answer: Context determines correctness.

Exercise 26: Name two contexts where rules matter.

Show Answer

Answer: Exams, academic journals, style guides, professional documents.

Part E: Evaluating Claims (Exercises 27–30)

Exercise 27: Name a first step in evaluating a grammar claim.

Show Answer

Answer: State the claim exactly.

Exercise 28: Name a source of evidence.

Show Answer

Answer: A corpus, a usage guide, or a reference grammar.

Exercise 29: Name a question to ask about a rule.

Show Answer

Answer: Is it a fact, a style preference, or a house rule? Does the reader require it?

Exercise 30: Fix the hypercorrection: He gave it to John and I.

Show Answer

Answer: He gave it to John and me.

Test Your Knowledge

Ready to check what you learned? Answer all 10 questions, then submit. You need 80% (8 of 10) to pass. Your answers are not stored.

Question 1:

What is a grammar myth?




Question 2:

Which is a myth?




Question 3:

What does prescriptive grammar do?




Question 4:

What does descriptive grammar do?




Question 5:

Since when has singular they been used?




Question 6:

Which is a hypercorrection?




Question 7:

Which is a controversy rather than a myth?




Question 8:

Which is standard in American English?




Question 9:

Why do context and audience matter?




Question 10:

What is a good first step in testing a grammar claim?




Frequently Asked Questions

What are grammar myths?

Grammar myths are supposed rules of English that are widely repeated but not supported by usage or history, such as never splitting infinitives or never ending a sentence with a preposition. Grammar myths are often relics of old prescriptive teaching.

What are grammar rules myths?

Grammar rules myths are the common “rules” that turn out to be preferences, conventions, or inventions, not facts of grammar. Grammar rules myths persist because they were taught as laws in schools.

What are grammar controversies?

Grammar controversies are points on which educated writers, usage guides, and style manuals disagree, such as the serial comma, which versus that, singular they, and data. Grammar controversies are best settled by evidence and by the reader’s needs.

What does debunking grammar mean?

Debunking grammar means testing a claimed rule against evidence from real usage and from history, and showing that it is a myth or a preference. Debunking grammar helps writers choose with confidence.

What are language myths?

Language myths are widely held false beliefs about language, for example that one dialect is more logical than another, that language change is decay, or that texting is ruining English.

Does this mean that grammar rules do not matter?

No. Real rules of grammar exist, and conventions matter in exams, journals, and professional writing. The aim is to know which is which.

How do I decide whether to follow a disputed rule?

Check the style guide your reader or publisher uses, ask whether the rule helps clarity, consider the context, and be consistent.

Conclusion

You now have a clear view of grammar myths and controversies: fifty common “rules” and the verdicts on them, prescriptive and descriptive grammar, how usage evolves, the main disputes, regional and social variation, formal and informal norms, and when rules matter. You can judge a claimed rule by its evidence and its context.

When someone states a grammar rule, ask what it rests on and whom it serves. Next, you will study the differences between British and American English.

▣ Sources and further reading
  • Garner, Bryan A. Garner’s Modern English Usage. 5th ed. Oxford University Press, 2022.: usage guidance with evidence.
  • Pullum, Geoffrey K. “The Land of the Free and The Elements of Style.” English Today 26, no. 2 (2010): 34–44.: a critique of some prescriptive rules.
  • Huddleston, Rodney, and Geoffrey K. Pullum. The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language. Cambridge University Press, 2002.: descriptive treatment of the disputed constructions.
  • Curzan, Anne. Fixing English: Prescriptivism and Language History. Cambridge University Press, 2014.: the history of prescriptive rules.
  • Merriam-Webster Dictionary: myth: the dictionary entry.
ⓘ About this page

Last reviewed: October 29, 2026. How it was made: drafted with AI assistance, then checked with automated tests (structure, links, answer keys, spelling) and against the sources above. A person has not yet read this chapter line by line. Found a mistake? Report it.